Carriers are tightening across several commercial lines as we head into fall. Property appetites are narrowing in coastal and wind‑exposed counties, and many carriers are quietly adjusting deductibles upward on renewals. Commercial auto continues to push rate, especially for fleets with mixed driver quality or incomplete telematics data.
For producers, this means two things:

• Start renewal conversations early — carriers are taking longer to underwrite.
• Submit cleaner applications — missing details are causing more back‑and‑forth than usual.

Fall is historically a “reset” season for underwriting, so expect appetite shifts to continue through November.

2. Coverage Gap Spotlight — Business Interruption Myths
A surprising number of insureds (and some producers) still believe BI coverage pays for “lost revenue.” It doesn’t. It pays for lost net income plus continuing expenses, and only when the loss is caused by a covered peril.
Scenario: A bakery shuts down for 10 days because a nearby water main break floods the street. The bakery wasn’t damaged — but customers couldn’t reach the store.
Common misunderstanding: “Business interruption will cover our lost sales.”
Reality: No coverage. There was no direct physical loss to the bakery, and the cause (municipal water main failure) is not a covered peril.
Producer takeaway: Use September to remind commercial clients what BI actually covers — and what it doesn’t.

3. Regulatory Quick Hit — Producer Authority Restrictions
Several states have issued reminders this quarter about producer authority limits, especially around:

• Binding coverage without carrier approval
• Misrepresenting coverage availability
• Issuing certificates that imply coverage not actually provided

These violations are showing up more frequently in audits. The safest path is simple: Never bind, promise, or imply coverage until you have written carrier confirmation.

4. Seasonal Risk Reminder — Fall Storm Prep
Fall storms bring wind, hail, and early cold snaps. Clients should:

• Trim trees and remove dead limbs
• Clean gutters
• Check sump pumps
• Inspect roofs for loose shingles
• Review flood coverage (especially AE and VE zones)

Producers who send seasonal reminders build trust and reduce claims friction later.​

5. Skill Builder — How to Read a Declarations Page Like a Pro
Most producers skim the dec page. The best producers study it.
Key areas to review with clients:

• Named insured accuracy — LLC vs. individual vs. DBA
• Locations listed correctly — especially for multi‑site businesses
• Coverage limits — match what was quoted
• Endorsements — confirm required forms are present
• Deductibles — property deductibles are creeping upward

A five‑minute dec‑page walkthrough during renewal meetings eliminates 80% of future misunderstandings.
​
6. Fun Segment — Insurance History Corner
In 1871, the Great Chicago Fire destroyed more than 17,000 buildings and bankrupted dozens of insurers. The disaster forced the industry to rethink underwriting, building codes, and fire protection.
It’s a reminder that the insurance industry has always evolved after major losses — and fall is a perfect time to help clients strengthen their own risk posture.

7. Client‑Facing Tool — Business Continuity Template
Producers can copy/paste this into client emails:
Business Continuity Quick Checklist

• Identify critical operations
• List key vendors and backup vendors
• Create emergency communication plan
• Store insurance documents digitally
• Review BI coverage limits
• Assign responsibilities for reopening after a loss

Clients love tools they can use immediately — and this one positions you as a proactive advisor.

The phone rings Monday morning.
“We've got water in the basement. Are we covered?”
The word water tempts people into quick answers.
Don't.
Water can arrive in very different ways.

• A broken pipe.
• An overflowing appliance.
• Water entering from outside.
• A drain or sewer backup.
• A sump problem.
• Groundwater.
• Foundation seepage.
• Storm conditions.

Or something else entirely.
The facts matter.
And the applicable policy language and endorsements matter.

STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.
The first question shouldn't be:
“Are you covered?”
And it shouldn't automatically be:
“That's flood.”
Instead, start with:
“Tell me what happened and where you believe the water came from.”
Notice what that question does not do.

• It doesn't promise coverage.
• It doesn't deny coverage.
• It doesn't force the customer's situation into a category before the facts are known.

It opens the conversation.

Why the Source of the Water Matters.
Two customers can both say:
“There's water in my basement.”
and be describing very different situations.

• One may be describing water from a failed plumbing line.
• Another may be describing water entering from outside.
• Another may have a drain or sewer backup.
• Another may have water associated with a sump problem.
• Another may be describing seepage or another condition.

The producer doesn't need to determine the claim from the customer's first sentence.
The producer needs to discover what actually happened and take the appropriate next step.

Work the Five Disciplines

HEAR: A loss may have occurred.
But the source and cause of the water are not yet clear.
That's important.
The producer should recognize that “water damage” is a description—not necessarily a coverage determination.


ASK: Slow the conversation down.
Ask:

• When was the water discovered?
• Where did it appear?
• What was happening when it occurred?
• Was there a broken pipe?
• Was there an appliance involved?
• Was there a drain or sewer problem?
• Was the sump involved?
• Did water enter from outside?
• Were there storm conditions?
• What property was damaged?
• Is the water still entering the property?
• Has anyone already taken steps to stop or limit the damage?

You're not trying to conduct the carrier's investigation.
You're trying to understand enough to take the next appropriate action.


VERIFY

• Follow the policy and the carrier's claim-reporting procedures.
• Review applicable endorsements when appropriate.
• But don't replace the claims process with an agency-desk decision.

A producer can help the customer understand the process without declaring:
“Your claim is covered.”
or:
“Your claim isn't covered.”
before the appropriate review has occurred.


DOCUMENT: Record the customer's description in the customer's own terms.
Document:

• When the loss was discovered
• What the customer said happened
• Where the water appeared
• The suspected source, if the customer identified one
• What questions were asked
• Instructions provided
• Claim-reporting information
• Any referral made
• The next action

Be careful about writing a conclusion that the customer never made.
There's a difference between:
“Customer reports water entering basement during heavy rain.”
and:
“Flood claim.”
The first records what the customer told you.
The second may be a conclusion that has not yet been established.


NEXT SAFE ACTION: Help the insured report the loss promptly when appropriate and let the carrier investigate and determine coverage under the policy and facts.
If the customer needs immediate guidance about protecting property from further damage, follow the carrier's applicable instructions and appropriate loss-mitigation procedures.
Don't guess. Don't promise. Don't delay the appropriate next step.

The Producer's Job Isn't to Become the Claims Adjuster. This is an important distinction.

• A good producer should understand coverage.
• A good producer should be able to explain insurance concepts.
• A good producer should recognize when a customer's description raises an important coverage question.
• But the producer doesn't need to turn every phone call into a claims investigation.
• Nor should the producer make a coverage determination simply because the customer wants an immediate answer.

The professional response is often:
“Let's make sure I understand what happened.”
Then:
“Let's get the loss reported properly.”
Then:
“The carrier can evaluate the claim under the policy and the circumstances.”
That's helping the customer.
And it's staying within the proper role.

Here's the Bigger Lesson. 
This isn't really a story about basements.
It's about labels.
Customers use everyday language.
Insurance professionals work with policy language.
A customer says:
“My basement flooded.”
That statement tells you something.
But it may not tell you everything you need to know.
The producer's job is to discover the facts before attaching an insurance label to the situation.
That's a valuable habit far beyond water losses.

Eddie's Takeaway: When a customer says:
“There's water in my basement. Am I covered?”
Don't rush to answer.
Start with:
“Tell me what happened.”
Then listen.

• Ask another question.
• Verify what needs to be verified.
• Document what the customer actually told you.
• And take the next safe action.

That's a coverage conversation.

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING. 
Ask your producers:
When you hear “water damage,” what is the first question you should ask?
The answer I'm looking for is:
“Tell me what happened and where you believe the water came from.”
Then give them these three statements:
“My basement flooded.”
“Water came through the basement wall.”
“A pipe broke in the basement.”
Ask:
Are those three statements telling you the same thing?
Then ask:
What additional questions would you ask before deciding what happens next?
That's a five-minute exercise that can teach more than a page of memorized coverage definitions.

Want to Know More? 
Water-related losses can involve several different insurance questions, and producers need to understand the differences before they can have a useful coverage conversation.
For a deeper producer-oriented discussion of flood exposures and flood insurance, explore the FYI Express+ How to Insure Flood Insurance guide.
​
LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS

DEPARTMENT 6 — 50 YEARS IN INSURANCE

After 50 years in the insurance business, I've learned something that still surprises me.
The mistakes that cause the biggest problems aren't always complicated.
Sometimes they're incredibly simple.

• A question wasn't asked.
• A change wasn't reported.
• An assumption was made.
• A conversation wasn't documented.
• A coverage limitation wasn't explained.
• A producer was in too much of a hurry.

And sometimes everyone involved thought everything was perfectly fine—until it wasn't.
Those are the mistakes that stay with you.

Mistake #1: Assuming Nothing Changed.
I've heard it thousands of times:
“Nothing has changed. Just renew it like last year.”
But people change.

• Families change.
• Homes change.
• Businesses change.
• Vehicles change.
• Occupancy changes.
• Use changes.
• Risks change.

Sometimes the customer doesn't even realize that the change is important to insurance.
That's why a renewal shouldn't be treated as simply pushing the same button another year.
Ask another question.

Mistake #2: Believing the Customer Knows What Matters.
Customers generally aren't insurance professionals.

• They don't necessarily know that moving a family member into the house could matter.
• They may not realize that a home business could create a coverage question.
• They may not think about a detached structure being used differently.
• They may not realize that renting the property occasionally creates a different conversation.
• They aren't necessarily withholding information.
• They simply don't know what they don't know.

That's why discovery belongs to the producer.

Mistake #3: Giving the Fast Answer.
A customer asks:
“Am I covered?”
The producer wants to be helpful.
So the answer comes quickly:
“Yes.”
Or:
“No.”
But insurance often requires something more useful:
“Tell me what happened.”
That simple sentence can prevent the producer from answering a question before understanding the facts.
I've learned that speed isn't the same thing as service.
Sometimes the best service is slowing the conversation down.

Mistake #4: Trusting Memory Instead of the File.
Every experienced insurance person has a memory bank.

• You remember how a carrier handled something years ago.
• You remember what an underwriter told you.
• You remember a claim that looked similar.
• You remember what you were taught.

But memory isn't a policy.
And what was true five years ago may not be true today.
That's why experienced producers can sometimes make a particularly dangerous mistake:
They remember the answer—but don't verify it.
Experience should make you better at knowing what to check, not less willing to check it.

Mistake #5: Failing to Document the Conversation.
This one has followed me for decades.
Someone says:
“I talked to the customer.”
Fine.
What did the customer say?
“I don't remember.”
What did you explain?
“I'm not sure.”
What did the customer choose?
“I think they wanted the lower option.”
That's when you discover the difference between having a conversation and documenting a conversation.
A good file doesn't depend upon someone's memory six months later.
If it matters, write it down.

Mistake #6: Thinking the Cheapest Quote Solves the Problem.
Price matters.

• Customers care about price.
• Agents care about price.
• Carriers compete on price.

But insurance isn't simply a contest to see who can produce the smallest premium.
The real question is:
What risk is the customer trying to transfer, and what does the proposed policy actually do about it?
A cheaper policy may have different limits, deductibles, exclusions, endorsements or other terms.
A producer's job isn't to make the customer buy the most expensive policy.
It is to help the customer understand the insurance decision being made.
Price should be part of the conversation—not the entire conversation.

Mistake #7: Assuming “No” Means the Conversation Is Over.
Sometimes a customer declines an option.
That's their decision.
But the producer can still educate.
“I understand. Let me make sure you understand what we're declining.”
Then document the conversation appropriately.
The customer may still say no.
That's okay.
A professional producer doesn't pressure the customer into buying something they don't want.
But a professional producer also doesn't confuse:
“The customer declined it”
with:
“The customer didn't need to understand it.”

Mistake #8: Forgetting That the Customer May Remember Your Words Forever.
The producer may think:
“I was just talking.”
The customer may hear:
“My insurance agent told me I was covered.”
Those two things can become very different memories.

• That's why producer language matters.
• Be careful with absolute statements.
• Be careful with promises.
• Be careful with assumptions.
• Explain what you know.
• Identify what needs to be verified.

And when the answer depends on the policy and circumstances, say so.

The Mistake That Still Scares Me Most.
After 50 years, I don't think the biggest danger is that a producer doesn't know something.
Nobody knows everything.
The bigger danger is when a producer doesn't realize they don't know.

• That's when assumptions become answers.
• That's when memory replaces verification.
• That's when a shortcut replaces discovery.
• And that's when a small conversation can turn into a big problem.
• I've made mistakes.
• I've watched other insurance professionals make mistakes.
• I've seen agencies learn expensive lessons.

And the older I get, the more convinced I am that many of those lessons could have been avoided by doing something remarkably simple:
Slow down. Ask another question.

What 50 Years Has Taught Me.
If I could put five rules on every producer's desk, they'd be these:
1. Don't assume.
Ask.
2. Don't guess.
Verify.
3. Don't promise what you don't control.
Explain.
4. Don't trust your memory when the file can tell the story.
Document.
5. Don't let speed become the enemy of good insurance practice.
Slow down when the situation deserves it.
That's not complicated.
But I've learned that simple doesn't mean easy.
It means repeatable.

Eddie's Takeaway: Insurance is a business of details.
But it's also a business of people.

• People move.
• People marry.
• People divorce.
• People buy things.
• People sell things.
• People start businesses.
• People change jobs.
• People add drivers.
• People buy boats, motorcycles, RVs and second homes.
• People rent property.
• People change how they use property.

And they don't always think to call their insurance agent when they do.
That's why we ask.
After five decades in this business, I still believe one of the most valuable things an insurance professional can say is:
“Tell me more.”
Because that's where discovery begins.

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING.
Ask each producer to write down the three most common assumptions they see customers make about insurance.
Then ask:
Which one of those assumptions could create the biggest problem if we never asked about it?
Don't turn this into a lecture.
Let the producers tell you what they're seeing.
You'll probably learn something from them.
And if you're the agency owner, that's worth remembering too:
The best producer-training conversations often begin with a question—not an answer.

Want to Know More?
The lessons above are really about developing better insurance professionals—people who know how to discover the risk, ask better questions, verify the facts, communicate clearly and take the next safe action.
That's the philosophy behind the FYI Express+ After the License — Producer Development Academy.

LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS

The customer calls at renewal and says:
“Nothing has really changed. Just renew the homeowners like last year.”
That sounds wonderfully routine.
The house is still standing. The mortgage is still there. The customer still owns it. The renewal offer is in the system.
A producer who is moving quickly can be tempted to accept “nothing changed” as a complete account review.
Then, almost as an afterthought, the customer says:
“We moved across town last spring. Our son is staying in the old house for now. He gives us some money every month to help with expenses.”
Now we have a very different conversation.
STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.

The address didn't change.
The ownership may not have changed.
But the occupancy and use did.
And those facts can matter enormously.
The first mistake would be deciding, from the agency desk, exactly what policy the customer needs.
The second would be pretending nothing changed simply because the named insured still owns the property.
The professional response is to slow the conversation down and discover the facts.

Work the Five Disciplines:
HEAR. The named insured no longer lives at the residence. An adult son occupies it, and money changes hands.
That's the fact that should make the producer stop.

ASK: Now we need the missing information.

• When did the insured move?
• Is the move permanent?
• Who lives in the old house?
• Is there a written lease?
• How much is being paid, and what is the payment for?
• Is any portion of the house vacant?
• Did the insured leave personal property there?
• Are there pets, a pool, a trampoline, business activity, roommates, or other occupants?

We aren't trying to turn a simple conversation into an interrogation.
We're trying to understand the risk before deciding what comes next.

VERIFY: Now verify the carrier's current requirements.

• What does the applicable policy say?
• How does the carrier treat this occupancy?
• What are its eligibility and underwriting requirements?
• What forms or options may be available?
• And what authority does the producer have?

Don't assume that family occupancy or an informal rental arrangement automatically preserves owner-occupied eligibility.

DOCUMENT: Create a useful record of the conversation.
Document:

• When the occupancy changed
• Who now occupies the residence
• How the customer described the arrangement
• The important questions you asked
• Any underwriting referral
• Options that were discussed
• What the customer selected or declined
• What happens next

Six months from now, another person in your agency should be able to read the file and understand what happened.

NEXT SAFE ACTION: Refer the changed occupancy and use to the appropriate carrier or underwriting resource and determine the proper path before representing that the existing arrangement remains appropriate.

What's Really Frightening?
The frightening part isn't that the customer did something unusual.

• Families keep old homes.
• Adult children move into their parents' property.
• Parents help their children.
• People relocate before deciding whether to sell.
• Some families exchange money informally without ever thinking of the arrangement as “renting.”

All of that happens every day.
The frightening part is how easily a producer can hear “same house, same owner” and completely miss “different occupancy, different use.”
That's how an ordinary renewal can become an insurance horror story.
And it started with three innocent words:
“Nothing really changed.”

Eddie's Takeaway: A renewal should never be merely an invitation to reproduce last year's policy.

• People change.
• Families change.
• Property changes.
• Occupancy changes.
• Use changes.

And sometimes the customer doesn't recognize that the change has anything to do with insurance.
That's why we ask.
STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING.
Before giving your producers the answer, ask them:
What questions does our agency ask at renewal that would uncover a residence the insured no longer occupies?
Then give them the original customer statement:
“Nothing has really changed. Just renew the homeowners like last year.”
See who asks the next question.
​​

Want to Know More?

This is only one example of how ownership, occupancy, and use can change a residential insurance exposure.
The FYI Express+ Residential Property Insurance training takes producers deeper into renters, condos, homeowners, manufactured and modular homes, secondary residences and residential transitions—with practical questions and real-world situations designed to teach producers to think beyond the quote.

LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS

​DEPARTMENT 2 — E&O DANGER ZONE

A customer calls with a simple question:
“If that big oak tree falls on my detached garage during a storm, am I covered?”
The producer wants to be helpful.
They know the account. They remember the homeowners policy. They have handled similar questions before.
So they answer quickly:
“Yes, you're covered.”
Two words.
Friendly. Reassuring. Efficient.
And potentially dangerous.

Why “You're Covered” Can Be a Problem.
Insurance professionals explain coverage every day.
That's part of the job.
But there is a difference between explaining a coverage concept and guaranteeing the outcome of a future claim.
Coverage can depend on the actual cause of loss, policy definitions, exclusions, conditions, endorsements, limits, deductibles, valuation provisions, the facts discovered during the claim, and applicable law.
That's why a producer should be extremely careful about turning a general coverage conversation into a promise.
The customer isn't necessarily asking for a legal opinion.
They're asking for confidence.
Give them professional guidance—not false certainty.

STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.
Before answering, find out exactly what the customer is asking.

• Is this a hypothetical question?
• Has the tree already fallen?
• Is there already damage?
• What property is involved?
• What exactly happened?

Those questions can change the conversation completely.

Work the Five Disciplines:

HEAR. The customer is asking for certainty about a future claim.
That's the first thing the producer should recognize.
The customer may not understand the difference between:
“Does my policy provide coverage for this type of loss?”
and
“Will my particular claim be paid?”
Those aren't necessarily the same question.

ASK: Slow the conversation down.
Ask:

• What property are we discussing?
• What prompted the question?
• Has something already happened?
• If something happened, when did it happen?
• What exactly occurred?
• Is this hypothetical or an actual loss?
• Are there other facts that might affect the situation?

The objective isn't to avoid answering.
The objective is to answer the right question.

VERIFY: Now verify the applicable policy language and endorsements when appropriate.
If an actual loss has occurred, follow the carrier's claim-reporting procedures rather than trying to adjudicate coverage from the agency desk.

• Don't rely solely on memory.
• Don't rely on what happened with another customer.
• And don't assume that because two situations sound similar, they will necessarily have the same result.

DOCUMENT: Create a useful record.
Document:

• The customer's question
• The facts the customer provided
• What was reviewed
• What was explained
• Any limitations that were discussed
• Any referral that was made
• Any claim-reporting instructions
• The next action

A file note that simply says:
“Spoke with insured about tree.”
doesn't tell the next person much.
A useful note should allow another competent member of the agency to understand the conversation.

NEXT SAFE ACTION: Use careful, professional language.
For example:
“Let's look at the policy and the facts before I give you an answer.”
Or:
“I can explain the general coverage provision, but an actual claim determination depends on the policy and the circumstances.”
Or, when appropriate:
“Since this has already happened, let's make sure the claim is reported promptly and let the carrier evaluate it under the policy.”
That's not evasive.
That's professional.

The Goal Isn't to Make Producers Afraid of Coverage Questions.
There's an important distinction here.
We don't want producers afraid to discuss insurance.
A producer who responds to every coverage question with:
“You'll have to call the carrier.”
isn't providing much value either.
A knowledgeable producer should be able to explain insurance concepts clearly.
The discipline is knowing where explanation ends, and certainty begins.

• You can explain.
• You can educate.
• You can identify the relevant policy provision.
• You can help the customer report a claim.
• You can explain what needs to be verified.

But you should be careful about promising an outcome that ultimately depends on the policy, facts, claims investigation, underwriting authority, or applicable law.

Eddie's Rule: Teach the Concept. Verify the Contract. Don't Promise the Claim. 
That's a simple rule worth putting on every producer's desk.
And it applies to much more than fallen trees.
It applies when a customer asks:

• “Is my jewelry covered?”
• “Will my basement flood be covered?”
• “Does my homeowners policy cover my business?”
• “If my son crashes the car, am I covered?”
• “Does my umbrella cover that?”

The answer shouldn't automatically be yes or no.
Sometimes the professional answer begins with:
“Tell me a little more about what happened.”

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING.
Ask your producers:
What phrases do we use when a customer asks, “Am I covered?”
Then write their answers on a whiteboard.
Look for phrases such as:

• “You're covered.”
• “That should be covered.”
• “I don't think that's covered.”
• “Your policy covers that.”

Then ask:
How could we say that more professionally without being unhelpful?
That's a much better training exercise than simply telling producers:
“Don't say you're covered.”
We want them to understand why.

Want to Know More?
This commentary is fundamentally about producer language, documentation, E&O prevention, and knowing the limits of your authority.
For a deeper look at those issues, explore the FYI Express+ E&O Prevention training resources.

LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS

Every agency has known some version of this producer.

• Customers love them.
• They remember birthdays.
• They can quote quickly.
• They know which underwriter to call.
• They solve problems over the phone.
• Their desk looks busy because it is busy.

And their file notes say things like:
“Spoke with insured.”
That is not documentation.
It is evidence that a conversation occurred.

The Problem Appears Six Months Later.
Six months later, the customer remembers being told one thing.

• The producer remembers saying another.
• The CSR wasn't on the call.
• The account has changed hands.
• Nobody can reconstruct what was offered, what was declined, what fact the customer disclosed, or why the agency took the action it took.
• Now everyone is trying to remember a conversation that should have been documented when it happened.

That's when a simple agency habit can become a very expensive problem.

STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.
When you hear:
“I talked to the customer about it.”
the next question shouldn't be:
“Did you?”
It should be:
“What did you document?”
Documentation isn't about creating paperwork for the sake of paperwork.
It's about creating a reliable record of what actually happened.

What Does Good Documentation Look Like?
A useful file note doesn't have to be a novel.
It should allow another competent person to understand the important parts of the conversation without having to find the producer and ask:
“What happened?”
A good note should generally capture:

• Date and participants
• Material information learned
• Questions asked
• Coverage or options discussed
• What was offered
• What was selected or declined
• Important limitations or unresolved issues
• Referrals made
• Next action

The exact level of detail will depend on the situation and your agency's procedures.
But “Spoke with insured” doesn't tell the story.

Work the Five Disciplines:

HEAR: The producer says the customer was contacted.
That's not enough.
The agency needs to know what was actually discussed.
A conversation can contain important information that disappears if nobody records it.

ASK:

• What did the customer tell us?
• What questions did we ask?
• What problem was the customer trying to solve?
• What options were discussed?
• Was anything offered?
• Was anything declined?
• Was additional information requested?
• What happens next?

These questions turn a vague memory into a usable record.

VERIFY: Before documenting a conclusion, make sure the conclusion is actually supported.

• Did the carrier confirm the issue?
• Did the producer actually discuss that coverage?
• Was an option really offered?
• Did the customer actually decline it?
• Was an underwriting referral made?

Document what happened—not what you wish had happened.

DOCUMENT: This is where the producer earns their keep six months later.
Write the note while the conversation is still fresh.

• Record the material facts.
• Record the customer's response.
• Record what you explained.
• Record what was offered.
• Record what was accepted or declined.
• Record what still needs to happen.

A good file should tell the story.

NEXT SAFE ACTION: Don't let documentation become the end of the process.
If the note says:
“Need carrier approval.”
Someone needs to know who is responsible for obtaining it and what happens next.
If the customer declined an option, make sure the file reflects the actual conversation.
If additional information is needed, identify it.
If a follow-up is required, establish it.
A good note should leave the next person knowing what to do.

Here's Where Agency Management Comes In.
Poor documentation is rarely only a producer problem.
If the agency has never defined what a good file note looks like, never audits files, never coaches weak documentation and rewards speed above completeness, management has helped create the problem.
You can't tell producers:
“Document everything.”
and leave them to guess what that means.

• Give them examples.
• Show them good notes.
• Show them bad notes.
• Review actual files.
• Coach them.

Make documentation part of the agency's normal workflow rather than something people remember to do when they have time.

The Five-Second Test.
Here's a simple agency test.
Pick a recently completed account.
Give the file to another employee who wasn't involved in the transaction.
Ask:
“Can you tell me what happened?”
If the answer is:
“Not really.”
you've discovered an opportunity for improvement.
Now ask:
“Can you tell me what happens next?”
If the answer is:
“I have no idea.”
you've discovered a second problem.
A good file should tell the story and identify the next safe action.

Eddie's Rule: If It Matters, Write It Down.Don't trust your memory.

• Don't assume you'll remember six months from now.
• Don't assume the person taking over the account will know what happened.
• Don't assume the customer remembers the conversation the same way you do.

Write it down while it's fresh.
That's not bureaucracy.
That's professional insurance practice.

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING.
Pull three recently completed files.
Don't tell the producers which ones you've selected.
Then ask someone who wasn't involved with the accounts to answer five questions:
1. What happened?
2. What important facts did the customer provide?
3. What was discussed or offered?
4. What did the customer decide?
5. What happens next?
If the file answers all five, you've got something worth replicating.
If it doesn't, you've got something worth teaching.

Want to Know More?
Good documentation is only one part of developing a producer who can consistently hear the customer, ask the right questions, recognize exposures, communicate professionally and take the next safe action.
For a broader look at producer development, explore the FYI Express+ After the License — Producer Development Academy.
​
LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS

DEPARTMENT 3 — ASK ANOTHER QUESTION
By Eddie K. Emmett | October 2026

• The homeowner's application is almost finished.
• The house looks ordinary.
• No pool.
• No trampoline.
• No obvious business exposure.

Then the producer hears barking in the background.
“Oh, that's Bruno,” the customer says. “He's harmless. Everybody loves him.”
That is not a reason to panic.
It is a reason to ask another question.
The producer's job isn't to decide whether Bruno is a good dog.
It's to discover the facts the carrier asks about—and the facts that may affect eligibility, underwriting, or liability exposure.

STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.
The first question shouldn't necessarily be:
“Does your dog bite?”
That's a yes-or-no question that may not tell you very much.
A better opening might be:
“Tell me about Bruno.”
Now listen.

• How old is he?
• How long has the customer had him?
• Has anything ever happened involving him?
• Where does he stay?
• Who regularly interacts with him?
• The goal isn't to interrogate the customer.

The goal is to discover the exposure.

The Questions Worth Asking:
Depending on the carrier's application and underwriting requirements, the producer may need to explore questions such as:

• How many dogs are in the household?
• What are their breeds or mixes, if known?
• Has any dog ever bitten, injured, chased or aggressively threatened a person or another animal?
• Has there ever been a prior claim, complaint, animal-control event or special restriction?
• Is the dog regularly around children, customers, tenants, delivery people or other visitors?
• Does the carrier have animal-related underwriting questions, restrictions or documentation requirements that need to be addressed?

The important point is that the producer shouldn't invent the rules.

• Don't assume every carrier treats every animal the same way.
• Don't rely on an old underwriting rule you remember from another company.
• And don't substitute your personal opinion of the dog for the carrier's requirements.
• “Bruno is a sweetheart” may be true.

It just isn't an underwriting answer.

Work the Five Disciplines:

HEAR: There is an animal exposure that wasn't previously discussed.
The producer heard something that wasn't obvious from the application.
That's the moment to slow down.

ASK: Obtain the facts relevant to the customer's liability exposure and the carrier's current application and underwriting questions.
Don't ask questions simply because you have always asked them.
Ask because the answer could matter.

VERIFY: Check the carrier's current underwriting requirements and policy provisions.

• Don't rely on memory.
• Don't assume that another carrier's treatment of the same situation applies here.
• And don't tell the customer that coverage exists—or doesn't exist—until you've verified what needs to be verified.

DOCUMENT: Record the important facts.
Document:

• What the customer disclosed
• The questions asked
• The customer's answers
• Any relevant prior incident disclosed
• Any carrier referral
• Any underwriting decision or instruction
• What the producer told the customer
• What happens next

A good file should tell the story without requiring everyone to remember the conversation.

NEXT SAFE ACTION: Complete the underwriting process accurately.
If additional information or carrier review is required, obtain it.
If the customer needs to consider another coverage solution, explain the issue without making promises.
Don't guess. Verify.

The Lesson Isn't Really About Dogs.
That's what makes this department useful.
The dog is simply the trigger.
The same thing happens when a producer hears:
“My brother is staying with us for a while.”
Or:
“We use the detached garage as a workshop now.”
Or:
“My daughter keeps her car here when she's home from college.”
Or:
“My wife started selling things online.”
Or:
“We rent the house for a few weekends every year.”
Each statement may be nothing—or it may change the insurance conversation.
The professional producer doesn't decide too quickly.
The professional producer asks another question.

What the Customer Doesn't Know Can Matter.
Most customers aren't trying to hide information.
They simply don't know which details matter to insurance.
That's why asking:
“Anything else?”
isn't always enough.
The customer may honestly answer:
“No.”
because, from the customer's perspective, nothing else seems important.
A better producer learns to recognize conversation triggers.

• A new dog.
• A new driver.
• A move.
• A renovation.
• A home business.
• A new vehicle.
• A rental arrangement.
• A new structure.
• A change in occupancy.
• A new recreational vehicle.
• A new source of income.

These aren't necessarily problems.
They're reasons to ask another question.

Eddie's Takeaway: A producer doesn't need to know every answer immediately.
But a producer should learn to recognize when another question is necessary before giving an answer.
That's one of the differences between simply processing an application and actually discovering the customer's risk.
And sometimes the entire discovery process begins with a bark in the background.
“Tell me about Bruno.”

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING.
Ask your producers:
What are five things a customer might casually mention during a homeowners conversation that should make you stop and ask another question?
Give them two minutes.
Then compare their answers.
You may be surprised how many different answers you get.
That's the point.
Producer development isn't just teaching people what to say.
It's teaching them what to notice.

Want to Know More?
Animal liability is only one part of a customer's broader personal liability picture.
When the account warrants a broader conversation, your FYI Express+ How to Insure Personal Umbrella guide can help producers explore the customer's overall liability exposure, ask better questions, and recognize situations that deserve a closer look.

LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS