The House That Wasn't Really Owner-Occupied

The customer calls at renewal and says:
“Nothing has really changed. Just renew the homeowners like last year.”
That sounds wonderfully routine.
The house is still standing. The mortgage is still there. The customer still owns it. The renewal offer is in the system.
A producer who is moving quickly can be tempted to accept “nothing changed” as a complete account review.
Then, almost as an afterthought, the customer says:
“We moved across town last spring. Our son is staying in the old house for now. He gives us some money every month to help with expenses.”
Now we have a very different conversation.
STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.

The address didn't change.
The ownership may not have changed.
But the occupancy and use did.
And those facts can matter enormously.
The first mistake would be deciding, from the agency desk, exactly what policy the customer needs.
The second would be pretending nothing changed simply because the named insured still owns the property.
The professional response is to slow the conversation down and discover the facts.

Work the Five Disciplines:
HEAR. The named insured no longer lives at the residence. An adult son occupies it, and money changes hands.
That's the fact that should make the producer stop.

ASK: Now we need the missing information.

• When did the insured move?
• Is the move permanent?
• Who lives in the old house?
• Is there a written lease?
• How much is being paid, and what is the payment for?
• Is any portion of the house vacant?
• Did the insured leave personal property there?
• Are there pets, a pool, a trampoline, business activity, roommates, or other occupants?

We aren't trying to turn a simple conversation into an interrogation.
We're trying to understand the risk before deciding what comes next.

VERIFY: Now verify the carrier's current requirements.

• What does the applicable policy say?
• How does the carrier treat this occupancy?
• What are its eligibility and underwriting requirements?
• What forms or options may be available?
• And what authority does the producer have?

Don't assume that family occupancy or an informal rental arrangement automatically preserves owner-occupied eligibility.

DOCUMENT: Create a useful record of the conversation.
Document:

• When the occupancy changed
• Who now occupies the residence
• How the customer described the arrangement
• The important questions you asked
• Any underwriting referral
• Options that were discussed
• What the customer selected or declined
• What happens next

Six months from now, another person in your agency should be able to read the file and understand what happened.

NEXT SAFE ACTION: Refer the changed occupancy and use to the appropriate carrier or underwriting resource and determine the proper path before representing that the existing arrangement remains appropriate.

What's Really Frightening?
The frightening part isn't that the customer did something unusual.

• Families keep old homes.
• Adult children move into their parents' property.
• Parents help their children.
• People relocate before deciding whether to sell.
• Some families exchange money informally without ever thinking of the arrangement as “renting.”

All of that happens every day.
The frightening part is how easily a producer can hear “same house, same owner” and completely miss “different occupancy, different use.”
That's how an ordinary renewal can become an insurance horror story.
And it started with three innocent words:
“Nothing really changed.”

Eddie's Takeaway: A renewal should never be merely an invitation to reproduce last year's policy.

• People change.
• Families change.
• Property changes.
• Occupancy changes.
• Use changes.

And sometimes the customer doesn't recognize that the change has anything to do with insurance.
That's why we ask.
STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING.
Before giving your producers the answer, ask them:
What questions does our agency ask at renewal that would uncover a residence the insured no longer occupies?
Then give them the original customer statement:
“Nothing has really changed. Just renew the homeowners like last year.”
See who asks the next question.
​​

Want to Know More?

This is only one example of how ownership, occupancy, and use can change a residential insurance exposure.
The FYI Express+ Residential Property Insurance training takes producers deeper into renters, condos, homeowners, manufactured and modular homes, secondary residences and residential transitions—with practical questions and real-world situations designed to teach producers to think beyond the quote.

LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS