The Scariest Words an Agent Can Say: “You're Covered.”

​DEPARTMENT 2 — E&O DANGER ZONE

A customer calls with a simple question:
“If that big oak tree falls on my detached garage during a storm, am I covered?”
The producer wants to be helpful.
They know the account. They remember the homeowners policy. They have handled similar questions before.
So they answer quickly:
“Yes, you're covered.”
Two words.
Friendly. Reassuring. Efficient.
And potentially dangerous.

Why “You're Covered” Can Be a Problem.
Insurance professionals explain coverage every day.
That's part of the job.
But there is a difference between explaining a coverage concept and guaranteeing the outcome of a future claim.
Coverage can depend on the actual cause of loss, policy definitions, exclusions, conditions, endorsements, limits, deductibles, valuation provisions, the facts discovered during the claim, and applicable law.
That's why a producer should be extremely careful about turning a general coverage conversation into a promise.
The customer isn't necessarily asking for a legal opinion.
They're asking for confidence.
Give them professional guidance—not false certainty.

STOP. ASK ANOTHER QUESTION.
Before answering, find out exactly what the customer is asking.

• Is this a hypothetical question?
• Has the tree already fallen?
• Is there already damage?
• What property is involved?
• What exactly happened?

Those questions can change the conversation completely.

Work the Five Disciplines:

HEAR. The customer is asking for certainty about a future claim.
That's the first thing the producer should recognize.
The customer may not understand the difference between:
“Does my policy provide coverage for this type of loss?”
and
“Will my particular claim be paid?”
Those aren't necessarily the same question.

ASK: Slow the conversation down.
Ask:

• What property are we discussing?
• What prompted the question?
• Has something already happened?
• If something happened, when did it happen?
• What exactly occurred?
• Is this hypothetical or an actual loss?
• Are there other facts that might affect the situation?

The objective isn't to avoid answering.
The objective is to answer the right question.

VERIFY: Now verify the applicable policy language and endorsements when appropriate.
If an actual loss has occurred, follow the carrier's claim-reporting procedures rather than trying to adjudicate coverage from the agency desk.

• Don't rely solely on memory.
• Don't rely on what happened with another customer.
• And don't assume that because two situations sound similar, they will necessarily have the same result.

DOCUMENT: Create a useful record.
Document:

• The customer's question
• The facts the customer provided
• What was reviewed
• What was explained
• Any limitations that were discussed
• Any referral that was made
• Any claim-reporting instructions
• The next action

A file note that simply says:
“Spoke with insured about tree.”
doesn't tell the next person much.
A useful note should allow another competent member of the agency to understand the conversation.

NEXT SAFE ACTION: Use careful, professional language.
For example:
“Let's look at the policy and the facts before I give you an answer.”
Or:
“I can explain the general coverage provision, but an actual claim determination depends on the policy and the circumstances.”
Or, when appropriate:
“Since this has already happened, let's make sure the claim is reported promptly and let the carrier evaluate it under the policy.”
That's not evasive.
That's professional.

The Goal Isn't to Make Producers Afraid of Coverage Questions.
There's an important distinction here.
We don't want producers afraid to discuss insurance.
A producer who responds to every coverage question with:
“You'll have to call the carrier.”
isn't providing much value either.
A knowledgeable producer should be able to explain insurance concepts clearly.
The discipline is knowing where explanation ends, and certainty begins.

• You can explain.
• You can educate.
• You can identify the relevant policy provision.
• You can help the customer report a claim.
• You can explain what needs to be verified.

But you should be careful about promising an outcome that ultimately depends on the policy, facts, claims investigation, underwriting authority, or applicable law.

Eddie's Rule: Teach the Concept. Verify the Contract. Don't Promise the Claim. 
That's a simple rule worth putting on every producer's desk.
And it applies to much more than fallen trees.
It applies when a customer asks:

• “Is my jewelry covered?”
• “Will my basement flood be covered?”
• “Does my homeowners policy cover my business?”
• “If my son crashes the car, am I covered?”
• “Does my umbrella cover that?”

The answer shouldn't automatically be yes or no.
Sometimes the professional answer begins with:
“Tell me a little more about what happened.”

TAKE THIS TO YOUR NEXT AGENCY MEETING.
Ask your producers:
What phrases do we use when a customer asks, “Am I covered?”
Then write their answers on a whiteboard.
Look for phrases such as:

• “You're covered.”
• “That should be covered.”
• “I don't think that's covered.”
• “Your policy covers that.”

Then ask:
How could we say that more professionally without being unhelpful?
That's a much better training exercise than simply telling producers:
“Don't say you're covered.”
We want them to understand why.

Want to Know More?
This commentary is fundamentally about producer language, documentation, E&O prevention, and knowing the limits of your authority.
For a deeper look at those issues, explore the FYI Express+ E&O Prevention training resources.

LEARN MORE →

↑ BACK TO OCTOBER CONTENTS